Adapted Academic Discussion
Management · Dr. Patel
This week, we are examining whether employers should give more weight to university degrees or practical experience. Supporters and critics often begin from different assumptions about fairness, effectiveness, and the proper use of limited resources. In your response, explain which approach you find more convincing and why. You may build on the comments already posted, challenge part of a classmate's reasoning, or introduce a different relevant perspective. Use a specific reason or example so that your contribution moves the discussion forward rather than simply repeating a position.
Maya
I would use degrees as an important signal because a completed program demonstrates foundational knowledge and sustained commitment. This approach could also make the policy easier to understand and evaluate over time. Even if it has some costs, a carefully designed pilot program could reveal whether the expected benefits actually reach the people who need them.
Leo
I would instead prioritize demonstrated experience because real projects show whether applicants can solve problems and work effectively with others. A policy can sound attractive in theory but create unintended consequences in daily life. Before making a broad change, decision-makers should consider who carries the cost and whether a smaller, more flexible solution could achieve the same goal.
根据当前 TOEFL Academic Discussion 题型改编，非 ETS 官方原题。 查看 ETS 当前题型说明